Casestudyinc.com Logo
Business & Management Case Studies
  • Case Studies
  • Articles
  • About
  • FAQ

Innovation Dilemma – 10 recommendations

February 9, 2012

Many global companies suffer from the absence of strong innovation. Here are ten recommendations on how to innovate to create competitive advantage for managers seeking to build products and services globally.

  1. Do not innovate. Build a product or service. Innovation happens.
  2. A strategy to make products to have eureka moments will not succeed. Instead focus on building the product or service and a eureka moment might just happen.

  3. Do not fear failure. Discuss it.
  4. Apple’s Apple III launched in 1980 was a commercial failure. General Electric Co. (GE) shares its best practices across its many units and officially discusses failures as well.

  5. Be aware of market, product and technological developments.
  6. Orkut, the social network by Google did not catch up with Facebook applications and platform.

  7. Patience is rewarding.
  8. Dennis Crowley, founder of Foursquare took about five years to come up with the idea and build the service.

  9. Why, what and How are your best friends.
  10. What are you going to build? Why are you going to build it and how are you going to achieve it? Any manager should ask these critical questions before venturing into product development.

  11. Learn, unlearn and relearn.
  12. In 2000, Virgin Airways invested $67 million in J2000 seats. Customers were unhappy with the discomfort caused by the seats and the investment was unsuccessful. However, Virgin did not give up. It invested $127 million to overhaul of the airline’s upper-class seats. In 2003, the newer seats were successful wherein flight attendants would flip over the back and seat cushions to make the bed.

  13. Analyze but do not paralyze. The customer may not know what he/she wants.
  14. Steve Jobs was not a big fan of consumer research. According to him, it is not the consumers’ job to know what they want. He believed, to build a great product, think like a consumer of the future not the past. Attention to details can destroy as much value as it creates.

  15. Negate negativity. Have a good budget.
  16. A short-term vision may hamper innovation. Negativity destroys much value.

  17. Imagine the unimagined.
  18. Eat well, stay healthy and more importantly sleep well (dreaming is important!).

Nissan Production Way

November 22, 2011

Toyota invented the Toyota Production System (TPS) and in 1994, Nissan developed the Nissan Production Way or NPW to outline its synchronized production philosophy. The idea was to improve the company’s productivity and effectiveness and have a global standard production system. So essentially, manufacture according to the real consumer order, thus coordinating all operations and materials.

After the Renault and Nissan alliance took place, Renault embraced the NPW in its plants to produce each other’s automobiles. Renault increased its productivity and decreased its defective parts percentage as a result.

Basic Principles of Nissan Production Way – Two Never Ending

  • Never ending synchronization with the customer – Synchronization of Quality, Cost (eliminate waste) and Time (reduced lead-time, on time delivery).

    Nissan uses the term “Douki-seisan” – sequenced and simultaneous/synchronized production to define the whole range of its highly productive NPW. The douki seisan concept helps cut lead-time across the supply chain, and begins & ends with the customer. After a customer places an order with a dealer, there has to be synchronization between the manufacturer, the supplier and the dealer with an efficient process flow without any disruptions.
  • Never ending quests to identify problems and put in place solutions – Identify gaps between desired manufacturing state and present manufacturing settings. Nissan uses the term “Genba kanri” – shop floor management to solve problems where they occur most (in the shop floor) and make improvements.

How the Nissan Production Way works

Here is a video from Nissan on its Nissan Production Way –

Companies and the Rural Push

November 17, 2011

With a faltering economy, many companies are sending their sales force into rural areas to increase sales and market share. MNCs like P&G, Unilever and Nestle are not only targeting the tier-1 rich consumers but also the very poor. Here is a look at the rural push by various companies:

Unilever in Pakistan – The Guddi Baji Program

Unilever, world’s second-largest consumer-goods company is aggressively pushing its beauty products in rural villages in Pakistan through Guddi Baji program. It hires beauty specialists and village women as sales representatives who understand rural women. They provide them with samples and equipment stocked in vans.

Hindustan Unilever in India

In 2011, Hindustan Unilever (HUL) was in talks with leading telecom firms and banks to create a joint distribution model to reach out to a wider rural market.

Colgate-Palmolive in Pakistan – 5000 to 15000 villages

Colgate-Palmolive, the world’s largest toothpaste maker is moving away from Pakistan cities by tripling the number of villages where its products like Colgate toothpaste are available.

ITC in India – Extending rural push

To extend the rural push, ITC collaborated with companies like Maruti Suzuki, Nokia and State Bank India (SBI) to connect with rural consumers. Rural consumers could thus get a chance to mingle with different companies and organizations under the ITC e-Choupal umbrella (rural distribution channel). The idea is to add more products to its rural distribution channels to increase awareness of its products and brands among rural customers. By 2011, ITC had around 6,500 e-Choupals in 50,000 villages across India.

Mahindra & Mahindra (M&M) – Rural Sales Drive

M&M, the car-maker increased its focus on the rural and semi-urban markets and gained by strengthening its after sales network in all districts of India.

Procter & Gamble (P&G) in China

To cater to poor people in developing markets, P&G introduced the “$2 a Day” project in China. P&G plans to target consumers with average income of $2. It calls them the “$2 a day” consumer. P&G’s team involves mostly technical people than market researchers who attempt to study and learn how best to develop products for the poor. The team devotes time by visiting homes in China and other countries like Brazil, and India.

U.S. Telecoms – Closing the rural divide

In July 2011, six major U.S. broadband companies (AT&T, CenturyLink, FairPoint, Frontier, Verizon and Little Rock-based Windstream) made a proposal to the FCC to speed broadband deployment to rural areas. There are more than 4 million Americans living in rural areas.

Coca-Cola – The ‘parivartan’ program – Training small town retailers

Coke’s new strategy involves training retailers (around 6,000 of them) in a program launched by the Coca-Cola University. [In 2007, the company launched Coca-Cola University — a virtual, global university for all learning and capability-building activities.]
The company calls this the “parivartan” program (meaning “Change” in English). Read More on Coke’s Rural push.

Pepsico – Affordable and accessible breakfast cereals in rural India

PepsiCo is targetting smaller cities in India for its breakfast cereals – like the Quaker Oats brand. The company wants to keeps the product affordable (@ Rs 5 for a bowl of Oats) and wants to educate the customer its health benefits in tier I and tier II cities of India.

Amazon – Amazing Facts

November 15, 2011

  • Amazon’s original name was Cadabra.
  • In the 1990s Amazon’s slogan was “Earth’s largest bookstore”.
  • In 2006, the company introduced an online TV and movie store.
  • Kindle e- book store was launched in 2007, and the MP3 digital music store in 2008.
  • Around 800 hardware and software engineers work at Amazon’s devices division in Cupertino, California.
  • Jef Bezos, founder of Amazon believes that the company is still in its infancy and hence the headquarters is named ‘Day one south’
  • The Lab126 Project – The 1 stands for a, the 26 for z.
  • The personalization team at Amazon are referred to as P13N – the 13 as per the count of letters in the word “personalization.”
  • The original Kindle was code-named “Fiona” after a character in Neal Stephenson’s futuristic novel “The Diamond Age”.
  • The latest in the Kindle series, the Kindle Fire had an internal code name – “Otter”.
  • n 2010, the average revenue per user (ARPU) for Amazon was US$189. This figure was eight times higher than Google’s ARPU of $24 and about forty times higher than Facebook ($4). Ebay had an ARPU of $39 while Yahoo had $8.
  • In 2011, its revenues were set to touch $50 billion in sales. To put that into perspective, Wal-Mart took around 33 years to match the figure (in double the time).
  • In a span of five years from the start, Amazon had revenues of $2.8 billion (1995-2000) compared to eBay’s $0.4 billion (1995-2000) and Google’s $1.5 billion (1998-2003).
  • In 2011, Amazon processed 35 orders per second during the holiday season.
  • in 2007, Amazon’s sales increased by 38% to $15 billion, but its profit more than doubled to $476 million.

Twittering Profits – Transformational business impact

November 4, 2011

Low-cost customer service

In 2008, Gartner identified Twitter as a disruptive technology that would change business in the coming years. According to some estimates, there are around 3 million users on twitter. Both large corporations and small businesses use the low-cost free micro blogging service for various purposes including gathering customer data, responding to customer grievances and even brand promotion. Many companies have official twitter accounts and even encourage employees to use it e.g., more than 400 Zappos employees use Twitter, Dell has 20 official Twitter accounts.

How companies are using Twitter?

Tracking Inventory – Can’t find a product at the store? Just tweet about it

In 2010, Indian FMCG Company Parle Agro used Twitter to track inventory. Customers and retailers could inform the company via Twitter whether there was enough stock of its baked wheat snack brand Hippo in their neighborhood stores. The results were good with the company receiving tweets from 25 cities regarding Hippo’s distribution and boosting sales by approx. 75%. With Hippo’s mass-distribution to five lakh retail outlets, Twitter served the company equaling almost half of Parle Agro’s foods sales team.

Consumer Complaints/Service – Instant action

Many companies monitor tweets by customers and respond immediately, e.g. Kingfisher Airlines Ltd. responded to a customer complaint on twitter on not finding a lounge at the airport within 15 minutes. ICICI Bank refills its ATMs when a customer complains by tweeting about it. JetBlue provides Twitter based customer service, even displaying the employee on duty at any time.

Useful brand-monitoring and corporate identity tool

Zappos looks at twitter as an opportunity to network with customers and improve its brand image. Zappos CEO Tweets many times in a day has many followers and around 400 employees use twitter to nurture a company culture. Samsung’s Twitter account focuses on mobile phones and product news.

Collecting Data, Focus groups

Many companies tweet about their product launches and get instant feedback on various issues. The user segmentation (usually gathered from the bios, profile of the twitter users) helps elicit opinion from the right target audience. Procter & Gamble (P&G) uses feedback on the quality of their products launched on twitter. Starbucks also tweets about new offers and shares details with its twitter followers. Wal-Mart uses Twitter to make a better shopping experience for its customers.

Nokia’s shadow program

November 2, 2011

Shadowing by colleagues

Colleagues follow every move of around 30 of Nokia India’s top management leaders for about a week. They observe what they do, how they do and learn from them. The management team selects top 30 Nokia leaders, not based on hierarchy but from any level who typify Nokia’s four values – PAVE – Passion for Innovation, Achieving Together, Very Human and Engaging You.

A unique HR program at the workplace

The shadow program introduced by Nokia India is a hit among Nokia’s other offices across the globe. While it is common for new recruits to follow colleagues as part of the induction program, the shadow program is unique in the sense that experienced colleagues follow leaders who live the company values. If the leader travels to a remote location, then the shadower follows suit. The travel expenses are not a constraint.

Unique Learning Benefits

Due to the informal network creation, both the leader and shadower get an exposure to insights and learning from other departments that would not have been possible otherwise. At the end of the shadowing, the shadowers write down their experience. The written information is then circulated among the top 30 leaders and contributes to improving their leadership skills as well.

Having leadership participate in such shadow programmes and share learning in the workplace, is a symbolic sign of leaders giving way to light (colleagues) where once they cast a shadow (not in a bad sense).

The Nissan Way – Power from within

October 12, 2011

Nissan, the Japanese automaker has a very simple management thinking known as the ‘The Nissan Way’. According to the Nissan way, the customer is prime focus, value creation provides the impetus and success is measured in terms of profit.

Nissan conducts various Nissan Way workshops where its business leaders share knowledge and educate fellow employees. The Nissan Way is different from the Nissan Production Way (NPW), it introduced in 1994. A document detailing ‘The Nissan Way’ is available in eight languages for its employees worldwide.

Five enablers to the Nissan way

Five elements of the Nissan Way

Nissan’s respect for Diversity

In 2004, Nissan formed the Diversity Development Office (DDO) and established a diversity steering committee to foster diversity. The DDO was especially useful given the cross-cultural nature of its alliance with Renault in 1999. With the DDO, Nissan could make full use of the women talent in the company (focusing on two key areas – women’s career development & work-life balance for employees) and create higher value. Nissan holds diversity workshops and provides training to women as part of its managerial training program. Nissan was recognized it’s Women in the Driver’s Seat initiative in 2008. By 2010, Nissan had doubled its percentage of female car-life advisors and technical advisors as compared to 2003.

Career Design support

Employees design their own career in consultation with their supervisors whom they meet twice a year. Supervisors evaluate their performance and discuss aspirations & goals. Japanese employees have two options to take new roles – Shift Career System (to apply for positions in their own department and work practice) and the Open Entry System (to apply for openly advertised positions). Nissan also developed the Expert Leader System to develop specific skills in a wide range of technical and nontechnical domains. The expert leaders in turn, train other employees by sharing knowledge during seminars and using other communication channels available within the company.

Culture of learning

Nissan recognizes the importance of learning for its employees. Its initiatives like the Learning Navigation system on its intranet and its Nissan Learning Center Management Institute provide many opportunities for learning.

Stronger Internal Communication

To promote communication and information sharing, Nissan has in place tools like the corporate intranet system called WIN (Workforce Integration @ Nissan). The company also conducts various surveys to get employee feedback. Newsletters, opinion-exchange meetings and in-house video broadcasts help information sharing across various production facilities. In 2009, Nissan began N-Square, an internal social networking service in Japanese (English in 2010) for employees.

Building safe workplaces

Nissan values human resources as its most valuable assets and employs a single unified set of safety standards globally. Nissan engages in human-friendly production and uses practices like ‘strike zone’ approach. In 2005, the company introduced Advantage EAP (Employee Assistance Program), a mental healthcare program, to take care of the mental health of its employees.

Dell – From Direct Sales to Channel Strategy

October 10, 2011

This management case study briefly discusses Dell’s channel strategy and partner program introduced to recapture its lost market leader position. The case further highlights how Dell has successfully transformed itself from its direct-sales-only mantra to building a successful reseller network within three years.

     

Case Contents

  • Introduction
  • Dell’s unique ‘direct build-to-order’ sales model
  • Dell’s Transformation over the years
  • The 80s – PCs by mail
  • The 90s – Extending Direct sales, user-customized systems & JIT
  • The 2000s – Moving towards a broad-based IT company
  • Dell – Quick Facts
  • Michael Dell – Leading from the front
  • Dell’s Channel Strategy
  • White Box program
  • Partner Program – Dell PartnerDirect
  • Three tiers in Dell PartnerDirect
  • Bibliography
  • Exhibit 1 – How Dell’s direct build-to-order’ sales model worked
  • Exhibit 2 – Five key elements in Dell’s successful Direct Model
  • Exhibit 3 – Dell – Business Segments
  • Exhibit 4 – Dell Historical Timeline
  • Exhibit 5 – Requirements for Dell PartnerDirect program
  • Exhibit 6 – Dell PartnerDirect Timeline – Dec 2007 to 2008
  • Exhibit 7 – Dell – Product Lines and Brands
  • Exhibit 8 – Dell Inc. – Historical Stock Chart
  • Exhibit 9 – Dell Inc. – Historical Income Statement
  • Exhibit 10 – Dell’s market share in Q1 2009 versus other PC makers

Sample Page of case study

[quote]”We don’t think about the channel as a second thought – it’s integrated into everything we are doing. Every new offering and capability has partners in mind.”
– Michael Dell in September 2011.[/quote]

[quote]“Our channel business continues to grow, continues to prosper, and we continue to attract new partners and grow our install base, and become a bigger and bigger part of the Dell portfolio.”
– Davis, Dell’s global channel chief in 2011.[/quote]

Introduction

In January 2007, Dell had lost its No. 1 position in worldwide PC shipments to Hewlett-Packard Company (HP). In 2011, Dell reported the largest revenue increase in the company’s history when it reported its results for financial year 2011. Within three years, Dell had successfully transformed itself from its direct-sales-only mantra to building a successful reseller network.

Dell has probably witnessed more changes in its business model than many other companies have. Dell is now engaging more with channel strategy and is on a channel-hiring blitz seeking ways to improve working with channel partners. Dell is making bigger investments in the channel with new innovative channel sales initiatives. The Dell channel business now amounts to about 33 percent of the company’s $62 billion in annual sales in 2011.

Japanese M&A in foreign markets – second-largest acquirers in the world in 2011

September 30, 2011

Importance of expanding overseas and competing on a global scale

In 2010, China had overtaken Japan as the as the world’s second-largest economy as Japan struggled with a stagnant economy. In March 2011, the quake & tsunami disaster disrupted factory production and shook Japanese companies. Earlier, they had focused only on the domestic market and had a reputation of being slow to expand in foreign markets. Now they have realized the importance of expanding overseas and competing globally.

The second-largest acquirers in the world in 2011

In 2011 YTD (through August 31), the number of global M&A deals stood at 617 and were valued at $1.8 trillion. According to Thomson-Reuter, there have been 380 Japanese M&A transactions across the border.

According to Dealogic, in 2010 Japanese firms spent $34.34 billion in global acquisitions. This year until date, they have spent more than $52.5 billion in global acquisitions. This makes them the second-largest acquirers globally this year (U.S. ranks one). A strong yen has helped them though it makes Japanese exports less competitive overseas. In 2008, they had spent a record $68 billion and are on way to exceed that figure.

Are Japan’s Foreign Acquisitions Right?

A Nikkei article reported that of all listed companies (reporting on March 31, 2011) had earned 80% of operating profits overseas. While foreign acquisitions may make the Japanese proud, many analysts think that Japanese firms must be more competitive through domestic consolidation and not be hasty to make acquisitions abroad. Analysts also think that Japanese firms are paying more than the actual valuation.

However, acquisition of U.S. companies will quicken the implementation of internationally recognized best governance practices and help focus on return on investment, which the Japanese give second preference over harmony and lifelong employment.

Japanese firms going global with overseas acquisitions

A few Foreign Acquisitions by Japanese corporations
Japanese Company Acquired Industry Amount Details
Asahi Group Holdings Ltd. Independent Liquor Ltd. Brewery $1.27 billion One of New Zealand’s largest beer companies
Toshiba Landis & Gyr Electricity metering equipment $2.3 billion Century-old Landis+Gyr, a prominent smart metering firm
Takeda Pharmaceutical Takeda Pharmaceutical Drug maker $14 billion Biggest deal of the year

Co-opetition – When Apple and Microsoft struck a deal

September 29, 2011

Sleeping With the Enemy

On Aug. 6, 1997, at the Macworld conference in Boston Steve Jobs announced the unthinkable. He announced a strategic partnership with rival Microsoft. The surprised audience first clapped then booed when they realized what had just been announced. Earlier, Apple had sued Microsoft for patent infringement.

“Apple needs help from other partners … and relationships that are destructive are no help to anybody in this industry today…We have to let go of the notion that for Apple to win, Microsoft has to lose.”
– Steve Jobs at the Macworld conference in Boston in 1997.

In 1997, Apple was struggling and Steve Jobs had just returned to save the company. Apple had lost more than a billion dollars with little sales growth. Microsoft on the other hand was the market leader and had loads of cash.

The Strategic Deal – From enemies to ending all legal hostilities

Apple and Microsoft signed a broad five-year patent-licensing agreement ending the legal hostilities.

  • For five years, Microsoft would release an Apple (or Mac) version of its leading Office product in addition to the Windows version. Bill Gates had remarked that around 8 million Microsoft users were on the Apple platform and the Mac Office 98 was more advanced than even the one on the Windows platform as it utilized the unique capabilities of the Mac.
  • Microsoft would invest $150 million in Apple shares (non-voting) and not sell it for three years.
  • Internet Explorer would be the default browser on the Macintosh platform. When the audience reacted negatively, Steve also announced that they would ship other browsers as well and it was up to the user to set any browser as their default. He also acknowledged Internet explorer as a good browser at the time.
  • Apple and Microsoft would ensure that each of their versions of the Java programming language were compatible.

Who won in the end

Some call the deal a masterstroke from Steve Jobs and credit his leadership skills. Well, the numbers do not lie – 14 year after the deal in 2011, Apple is the most valuable company with market capitalization at approx. $375 billion and ahead of Microsoft’s market cap at approx. $210 billion.

Below is a video of Jobs’s 1997 keynote

«‹ 2 3 4 5 ›»

Recent Posts

  • Operational Secrecy – Innovating in “secret”
  • Boomerang CEOs aka Founder Recall
  • How companies listen to their customers
  • Developers as Happiness Engineers
  • Management Gurus and what they are known for

Recent Comments

  • MKJ on How to write a case study?

Categories

  • Articles
  • Business Ethics
  • Business Strategy
  • Case Study
  • Dell
  • Entry Strategy
  • GE
  • HP
  • HR Case Studies (HRM)
  • IBM
  • Innovation Management
  • IT Cases
  • Jack Welch
  • Leadership and Entrepreneurship
  • Marketing Management
  • Mergers and Acquisitions
  • Nokia
  • Oprah Winfrey
  • Retail
  • Supply Chain Management (SCM)
  • SWOT Analysis
  • Tesco
  • Turnaround Strategy
  • Uncategorized
Business & Management Case Studies
  • Privacy Policy
  • FAQ
  • RSS
  • About
  • Helpdesk
© Business & Management Case Studies 2023

↑ Back to top